← Moon Dog · Rainwater Harvesting
The best rain barrels and diverters (2026)
A rainwater system is really four jobs: catch the water off the roof, clean it on the way in, store it, and get it back out. Most people buy a barrel and stop there, then wonder why the water is full of grit and the barrel overflows against the foundation. The fix is cheap and modular — a diverter handles overflow automatically, a first-flush diverter dumps the dirty first rinse of the roof, and a screen or filter keeps leaves and mosquitoes out. This guide covers each part and what to buy.
Some links below are affiliate links — if you buy through them, Moon Dog may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only point to gear we'd actually use.
Quick picks by part
| The job | What to get | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Store 50 gallons | Rain barrel + diverter kit | Easiest entry point; diverter handles overflow |
| Tap into the downspout | Downspout diverter kit | Auto-returns overflow to the downspout |
| Cleaner water in | First-flush diverter | Discards the dirty first rinse of the roof |
| Keep out leaves & bugs | Downspout filter + screen | Stops debris and mosquito breeding |
| Store 275+ gallons | IBC tote + linking kit | Big capacity per dollar; expandable |
| Mosquito control | Bti mosquito dunks | Kills larvae, safe for plants and pets |
The barrel (the entry point)
A 50-gallon barrel is the standard starting size — big enough to be useful for a garden, small enough to move and place under a downspout. Look for opaque, UV-stable polyethylene (light-blocking keeps algae down), a fine debris screen on top, a brass or sturdy plastic spigot near the bottom, and a front-facing overflow port. The Good Ideas Rain Wizard 50-gallon barrel with diverter kit is the popular all-in-one: flat-back design to sit against a wall, brass spigot, mesh screen, and a downspout diverter in the box. If you'd rather buy the barrel alone, a 50-gallon rain barrel with spigot and screen covers it. Tight on space? A collapsible 50-gallon rain barrel folds away in the off-season.
The diverter (overflow without the flood)
A downspout diverter is the single best upgrade over a bare barrel. It cuts into the existing downspout and routes water sideways into the barrel; when the barrel fills, it sends the rest back down the downspout instead of overflowing onto your foundation. A rain barrel downspout diverter kit is the generic version that fits most rectangular and round downspouts; the EarthMinded FlexiFit diverter kit is a well-regarded universal option that installs directly into your existing downspout. If you want a winter-friendly setup, look for a diverter with a closeable flap or valve so you can shut off the barrel before a freeze.
The first-flush diverter (cleaner water)
The first water off a roof in any storm is the dirtiest — it's rinsing off dust, pollen, bird droppings, and whatever settled since the last rain. A first-flush diverter (sometimes called a roof washer) is a vertical chamber that captures and discards that first volume before clean water is routed to the barrel. As the chamber fills, a ball float rises and seals it off; once full, the rest of the flow passes through to the tank, and the captured "first flush" drains slowly out a small release valve to reset for the next storm. A downspout first-flush diverter kit mounts on each downspout that feeds your tank. This part matters far more if you ever intend to treat the water for potable use.
The filter and screen (keep it out, not get it later)
Stopping debris at the entry is much easier than cleaning it out of the barrel. A downspout filter catches leaves and grit before they reach storage, and a fine 1/16-inch mesh screen on the barrel inlet blocks the gap mosquitoes need to breed. For mosquitoes that still find their way in, Bti mosquito dunks use a natural bacterium (Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis) that kills larvae but is harmless to plants, pets, and wildlife — one dunk per ~50 gallons.
Scaling up: IBC totes
When 50 gallons stops cutting it, an IBC tote is the cheapest way to jump to serious storage. A standard caged tote holds 275 or 330 gallons in a compact footprint, and a food-grade 275-gallon IBC tote is the one to buy if water quality matters (you know what was in a food-grade tote; reused chemical totes you don't). Totes link together for more capacity using an IBC tote linking kit at the built-in outlet valves, and a bulkhead fitting kit lets you add inlets and outlets anywhere on the tank. Add a brass spigot for a clean draw-off point.
Start with a barrel and a diverter — that covers most gardeners. Add a first-flush diverter and a filter when you want cleaner water, and step up to IBC totes only when you've proven you'll actually use the extra storage. Don't buy capacity you can't fill: a barrel that never overflows is oversized for your roof and rainfall.
Size it before you buy
The biggest mistake is guessing at capacity. A single inch of rain on a 1,000 sq ft roof yields roughly 620 gallons — so a couple of 50-gallon barrels fill and overflow fast, while an IBC tote might rarely top off. Run your own roof and rainfall numbers in our rainwater collection calculator before you decide how much to store. And if you're even considering drinking the water, read is rainwater safe to drink? first — the gear above is built for garden use unless you add real treatment.
Sources
- Bob Vila — rain barrel testing and picks (2026)
- BlueBarrel Rainwater and NTO Tank — how first-flush diverters work
- IBC Tanks — IBC totes for rainwater harvesting; Rutgers NJAES FS1240 — rain barrels and mosquitoes (Bti)
Affiliate picks for general garden-use rainwater collection. Products and prices change; the search links point to current listings. For potable use, none of this gear makes water drinkable on its own — see the safety guide and your local rules.